Is the Paris Agreement a Toothless Tiger?

      Commentaires fermés sur Is the Paris Agreement a Toothless Tiger?

Mr. Gérard Montpetit describe the global struggle between obsolete fossil fuels and the new technologies, and their numerous subtle punches. The opponents of the Paris Conference are demanding that Mr Trump remain in the Agreement in order to effectively gut it from the inside.


Is the Paris Agreement a Toothless Tiger?

With the swearing in of Mr Trump last January, political analysts foresaw a marked regression in American environmental policies. The nomination of climate change deniers like Scott Pruit to the helm of the EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) seemed to sound the death knell for international commitments of the world’s most powerful economy regarding the reduction of greenhouse gases (GHG). Besides, the hawks surrounding Mr Trump are urging him to reject the Paris Agreement (COP21) as he promised during the electoral campaign.i,ii

Surprise! The coal producers are doing an about-face and are asking Mr Trump to not repudiate the Paris Agreement.iii They are not doing this because they are convinced by the science from the International Panel of Climate Change (IPCC). Rather, it is a Machiavellian plot to promote “clean coal”, that is, carbon capture and sequestration (CCS); the coal is burned while trying to “wash” the noxious fumes that escape from the chimney. We have seen the Kemper County project in Mississippi, a $5 billion project, awash in a sea of insurmountable technical problems.iv I believe in “clean coal” with as much certainty as I believe that Santa Claus can come down 250 million chimneys without a trace of black soot on his fine red costume.

But there is a more diabolic reason to “save” the Paris Conference from the claws of Steve Bannion and Scott Pruit. Certain coal producers, such as Peabody Energy, are proposing the following strategy to Mr Trump: “The future is in foreign markets. So the last thing you want, if you are a coal company, is to have to leave the negotiating table because of the American position, thus allowing the Europeans to control the agenda.”v In other words, stay in the conference to gut it from the inside, thereby transforming it into a toothless tiger !

Coal, the oldest and dirtiest of fossil energies, is trying to regain its former importance, even if it means driving the final nail in the coffin of climate change. On the other side of the planet, the prime minister of Australia, Mr Malcolm Turnball, is preparing to give the green light to the gigantic Carmichael coal mine in the Galilee basin; in order to kickstart this project, he is ready to hand over one billion Australian dollars in This fuel is destined for India; Australian coal or solar energy are the choices of this emerging economy which wants to bring the benefits of electricity to its billion citizens. Not only would this coal produce an estimated 7.7 billions tonnes of GHG during its expected 60 years of operation, it would multiply the risks to the Great Barrier Reef, already threatened by severe episodes of coral bleaching. Clearly, the dinosaur is refusing to die!

The scope of the fight against pollution is planetary; the new technologies are accelerating the inexorable demise of fossil fuels. Here too, there are great contradictions! China, the world’s second largest economy, but the greatest emitter of GHG, is faced with an apocalyptic level of pollution.vii Each day, 4400 Chinese die from the emissions coming, in large part, from coal fired power stations. This country experiences great problems of productivity due to the degraded pulmonary health of its population; this severely puts at risk China’s ambition to again become the “Middle Kingdom” at the center of the world.viii

It is in this context that the Chinese government has adopted its latest 5 year plan, about which one may read the following commentaries from experts: “The 13th plan is particularly symptomatic of the willingness of the Chinese to take the world leadership on environmental questions. In effect, the authorities are aware of the risks of destabilization and political challenges by Chinese citizens with their associated economic and financial issues.”ix At Davos, several articles report the willingness of China to become the leader in green energies.x

In the United States, the rear-guard battle by the dinosaurs in the White House may attempt to stem the waves of creativity coming from Silicon Valley headed by people such as Elon Musk. It is, merely,the death throes of dinosaurs! The 11 of March, hardly two months after Trump’s swearing in, California succeeded in producing 50% of its electricity from renewables, the majority of which (40%) came from solar panels.xi Even the conservative state of Texas, that great oil producerxii, has become the state which produces the most electricity from wind with a capacity of 20,321 megawatts according to Wikipedia.xiii

On the eve of Earth Day, it is clear that the efforts to transform the Paris Conference (COP 21) into a harmless, toothless tiger will accentuate the damage caused by climate change. This will put in peril the poorer and more vulnerable nations. This Autumn, COP 23, which will be presided over by the prime minister of Fiji, Mr Bainimarama, will symbolically illustrate the narrow-minded egoism of the Trump regime.xiv

Gérard Montpetit

Member of comité des citoyens et citoyennes pour la protection de l’environnement maskoutain

April 19, 2017